Home / Reductions / Menacing / Erie

Menacing Plea Deals in Erie County

343 convictions · Erie County Courts · DCJS Data (2019–2024)

Based on 343 conviction records, Menacing is reduced to a lesser charge in 83.4% of cases in Erie County. The most common reduction is to Harassment (46.9% of reductions). The statewide average reduction rate for Menacing is 82.4%.

Charge reduction means the conviction charge differs from the original arrest charge, typically through plea negotiation. Only reductions with 3+ occurrences are shown. Data sourced from New York DCJS Pretrial Release Data. Last updated: March 2026

Charged with Menacing in Erie County? An attorney familiar with this court can evaluate your plea options.

Talk to a Erie County Attorney — Free
83.4%
Local Reduction Rate
82.4%
Statewide Average
343
Total Convictions

What Menacing Gets Reduced To in Erie County

The most common conviction charges when Menacing is reduced through a plea deal in Erie County.

Conviction Charge Count % of Reductions
Harassment 134 46.9%
Disorderly Conduct 126 44.1%
Weapons Offense 12 4.2%
Assault 6 2.1%
Other 5 1.7%
Criminal Trespass 3 1.0%

Source: New York DCJS Pretrial Release Data (2019–2024) — NewYorkCourtFile.com

Compared to Statewide

Erie County reduces Menacing charges at a higher rate (83.4%) than the statewide average (82.4%). This suggests more active plea bargaining for this charge in Erie County courts.

See Menacing reduction rates across all New York counties →

About Plea Bargaining in Erie County

Plea bargaining is a central part of Erie County's criminal court process. The data above shows actual reduction outcomes from DCJS records — not predictions. Every case is unique, and the plea offered in your case depends on the specific facts, evidence, your attorney's negotiations, and the local prosecutor's policies. Past outcomes do not predict future results.

How we calculate: We compare the arrest charge to the conviction charge for guilty outcomes. When the conviction charge category differs from the arrest charge category, we count it as a reduction. Minimum threshold: 3 reductions per combination. Data from DCJS Pretrial Release Data, last updated March 2026.

Other Charge Reductions in Erie County

Drug Possession
2,332 reductions
Other
1,173 reductions
Petit Larceny
1,142 reductions
Assault
1,091 reductions
Drug Sale
974 reductions
Burglary
702 reductions
Grand Larceny
702 reductions
Criminal Contempt
569 reductions

Common Questions

Statistics from public court records for informational purposes only. Not legal advice. Past outcomes do not predict future results.

Menacing is reduced to a lesser charge in 83.4% of convictions in Erie County, based on 343 records from DCJS Pretrial Release Data (2019–2024). The statewide average is 82.4%.
The most common reduction for Menacing in Erie County is to Harassment, accounting for 46.9% of all reductions (134 cases). For guidance on your specific case, consult a licensed New York attorney.
Erie County has a 83.4% reduction rate for Menacing, compared to the statewide average of 82.4%. This county reduces Menacing at a higher rate than average, suggesting more active plea bargaining. Differences reflect local prosecutorial practices and court customs.

Data source: New York DCJS Pretrial Release Data. 343 conviction records analyzed for Menacing in Erie County. Last updated March 2026. — NewYorkCourtFile.com

Next Step

Facing a Menacing charge in Erie County? An attorney who handles these cases in this court can walk you through your options.

Talk to a Erie County Attorney — Free Free · No obligation · Confidential